Uncle Hyena (unclehyena) wrote,
Uncle Hyena

Ghost in the Shell

Once upon a never was, there was a cyborg named Motoko Kusanagi who had earned the rank of Major in a paramiltary police organization, and who spent a lot of time wondering just where the machine ended and she began. After most of 30 years and many iterations, that much has always held true.

So now we have a live action "Ghost in the Shell" movie, and, well, they have screwed that up. Sort of. By the time the film ended I had forgiven it its many (many, MANY) foibles, and was very glad I had seen it, but it was a long road.

Random thoughts:

This is a visually stunning movie. The action sequences are often downright lyrical.

The "whitewashing" flap was unnecessary. Kusanagi's appearance is entirely synthetic, and quite frankly, Scarlett Johansen looks a LOT like many of the official illustrations. When all is said and done, there is nothing about this story or its philosophy that is fundamentally Japanese other than the authorship and the character names; the concepts and situations are pretty much universal.

On the other hand, I was REALLY upset that they whitewashed Kusanagi's name; the name is at the heart of the character continuity. Eventually, they fixed it, and did it so well that I have forgiven them.

"Major" is a TITLE. (At least most of the time, and definitely in this case.) Referring to someone as "Major" is inappropriate except in direct address, NEVER in first or third person. ("The Major", on the other hand, is fine.)

The decision to tell an origin story was at best dubious and probably wrong. Kusanagi originally appeared fully formed, like many other iconic characters, and has never been the worse for it.

I can say to the second the moment when I stopped grumbling about this movie and started to actually like it. It was when one of the characters said, "Never send a rabbit to kill a fox." This pushed a BUNCH of my happy buttons.

Philosophically... Honestly, this has been window dressing from day one. Characters have talked about the ramifications of the mind/ brain (machine) problem over coffee since forever, and have never said anything of substance, and never will, and who cares? It is all idle speculation in the face of experimental ignorance, and will continue to be so for the foreseeable future.

In the end, if you like this kind of thing, this is the kind of thing you will like.

Uncle Hyena
  • Post a new comment


    default userpic
    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.